The quest for supreme quality for an MMORPG

I think it should be an mmo Single player games are not mmos, which is why they can't have the quality on the same lvl, nor should they, because what's fun in a single player game is quite far from what's fun in an mmo. Well, at least imo.

We have not received permission from fogovivo to share the quoted post.

I know they're great online games and especially amazing for the RP crowd. But your OP didn't talk about either of those games. You said you want Ashes to be RDR2 and not like other mmos. If you had written that it should appeal to the RPers more and have a deep world with a ton of mechanics, then I'd probably agree, but I would also say that they're already doing that, but also that quite a lot of mmos are also already doing that.

You posted 2 videos. One about a mundane "go and find the thing" quest and another about pvp. How is that any different from any mmo out there? If you wanna prove your point, at least make good arguments for it.

And as others said, good graphics do not a good game make. Though even there we're covered, because Ashes will have UE5 working for it.

In other words, it seems that this thread was kinda pointless cause we already have what you're asking for.

We have not received permission from Arya_Yeshe to share the quoted post.

Forget CrowdFunded MMOs, bring on the CrowdSourced MMOs, eh?